Friday, September 9, 2022

Quick Reviews: Pride & Prejudice Retellings

A Certain Appeal by Vanessa King (2021)

A contemporary retelling of the classic Pride & Prejudice, set in and around a New York City burlesque show.  Liz Bennet was an aspiring interior designer until an incident at her internship forced her to give up her dream.  She made her way to NYC and started working at a burlesque show, where she ultimately meets Will Darcy.  I tend to really enjoy P&P retellings, and there was a lot to like about this one.  I liked the way the author updated the characters; Jane is now Liz's gay best friend and her other sisters have been replaced by a found family at the burlesque show.  Although a bit clumsy with his words (when he can actually get one in), Will Darcy is dreamy - handsome, successful, and totally into Liz.  The chemistry between them just oozed off the page; the tension between the two is the heart of the original story, but I liked that the author brought them together more quickly in this version.  I expect that retellings generally won't deviate too much from their original source material, but my quibble here is that it almost followed it too closely, despite the modern setting.  There's really no question because you know exactly how everything will turn out.  King's lush writing definitely helps, but I felt myself looking for something a bit more.  3.5 stars

Accomplished by Amanda Quain (2022)
 
This Pride & Prejudice retelling focuses on one of the secondary characters of the original book, Georgiana Darcy, as it modernizes the story and reimagines it set at an elite private high school.  I loved that this story wasn't about the main couple, but rather tells a new story from a different point of view.  Here, Georgiana (Georgie in this modern version) has been duped by Wickham, who was selling drugs from her dorm room without her knowledge, and she is returning to school as a pariah.  But Georgie isn't ready to give up, and she hatches a plan to reclaim her good name.  I liked the parallels to the original, although this story definitely doesn't rely too much on it, so it feels really fresh.  I felt for Georgie and was rooting for her to succeed, but at times her plans felt so... I don't know, singular?  Not well-thought out?  There wasn't a lot of nuance; it was more like, "If I do this one thing, everything will be fixed," without necessarily thinking through all the consequences.  I guess, to be fair, she is a teenager, but it reinforced my feelings that YA is no longer a top genre for me.  3 stars


* This post contains affiliate links; I earn a small commission on qualifying purchases, at no cost to you.

16 comments:

  1. Thanks for these quick reviews! I love a good Austen retelling. I'll have to add A Certain Appeal to my TBR list. I have seen Accomplished around and was definitely curious. I hear you about YA books. Lately the genre has really not been my favorite, which is sad, b/c it used to be my go-to. Maybe I am just too old now? haha.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Haha, yes, I am feeling too old for YA these days - I just can't deal with all the nonsense drama!

      Delete
  2. I always feel like I enjoy these retellings more because I have not read the originals. (Full disclosure - I have read so many retellings that I had to watch some of the films and read the Cliffs Notes to gain some familiarity with the original stories. I have not real love for them though)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I enjoyed the original story and like to see the parallels in retellings, but I can see the appeal of going in blind! I think it really shows how timeless the classic is.

      Delete
  3. I like the idea of the second one being reimagined at an elite school. Fun! Although same- I've been reading less YA lately.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, private schools are always a fun setting!

      Delete
  4. A Certain Appeal sounds interesting!!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I like a retelling that is faithful to the original, but I also want it to have something new and fresh. Too bad A Certain Appeal didn't manage to do that.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I know - other than the modern setting, it was really similar to the original.

      Delete
  6. I find myself perking up at the thought of Accomplished from Georgina’s POV! Though point taken, it is very much a YA novel.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 👋 That was me, BTW, Verushka from Pop. Edit. Lit

      Delete
    2. Hi, Verushka! Yes, I love the idea of a side character taking the lead!

      Delete
  7. I get that you want a little variation in the plot of a retelling! Sometimes you just want a little element of surprise. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Right? I like to see the similarities, but I also want it to be unique in some way.

      Delete
  8. I do like that both retellings have a nice twist - the burlesque setting or the focus on a secondary character. But sorry to hear A Certain Appeal also followed the original too closely, that kind of takes away some of the fun of a retelling.

    ReplyDelete

I'm so glad you stopped by, and I would love to hear your thoughts! Comments are always greatly appreciated!