Friday, August 28, 2020

Quick Reviews: A Trio of Cinderella Retellings

 Glass Slippers, Ever After, and Me by Julie Wright (2019)

Struggling writer Charlotte finally gets her big break with a self-help book inspired by her favorite fairy tales, but will the success be worth it if she has to completely change her image and hide her boyfriend?

This was a cute story, very loosely inspired by Cinderella.  Charlotte is a regular girl, but her publicist insists she needs a more polished image, including pretending she's single, just around the same time she and her best friend Anders decide to start dating.  Anders is a sweet guy, very traditional and family-oriented.  I liked the peek behind the curtain of the publishing industry, and I wish there were more scenes with a fellow famous author who takes Charlotte under her wing because she gave really good advice.  This is a "clean" romance, which is perfectly fine, but I also never really felt the spark between Charlotte and Anders and was hoping for a little more heat.  There were also some weird time jumps and sometimes it felt like more was happening off the page than on.  But, easy to read with some charming supporting characters.  3 stars

Rogue Princess by B.R. Meyers (2020)

Sci-fi Cinderella in space!  A princess who wants to marry for love!  A thief that helps her uncover a rebellious faction on their planet!  Practically the whole time I was reading this book, I got the feeling I had read it before - it's very similar to Marissa Meyer's Cinder, even little details like the tablets everyone uses, although this one is a gender-swapped retelling.  So, unfortunately, right from the start, I had issues because nothing felt new and fresh.  Delia, our princess, is bland and not too smart - when she first meets Aidan, our thief, his lies about who he was were so paper-thin, yet she never saw through them.  The world-building is not great, and even by the end of this rather short book, I was still questioning who some of the characters were.  But, there is a pretty good twist, and Delia's sister Shania is a bright spot in the story - she's spunky and I loved her attention to detail in analyzing all of Delia's suitors.  3 stars

Charlie Glass's Slippers by Holly McQueen (2014)

After his death, Charlie Glass's father leaves his luxury shoe company to her - instead of his ex-wife and two other daughters.  In addition to her new responsibilities, Charlie has also drastically changed her appearance, but finds it may not be worth the effort.

I thought this was a cute Cinderella retelling.  I loved the clever ways the the author incorporated important elements of the original story in a modern way - her glam up, the shoes, the evil stepmother, the prince.  Charlie has not had an easy life, but she's still upbeat and kind.  Even though she never worked at the shoe company before, she throws herself into it wholeheartedly, knowing it was her father's passion.  There's also a rom-com element to the story.  I think many readers will identify with her body issues, even after she loses a bunch of weight.  There is a lot of fat-shaming in this book, and my heart broke for Charlie every time her stepmother was cruel to her.  The book probably could have been a bit shorter - at times the pacing dragged and felt repetitive.  However, it was still light and entertaining.  3.5 stars

14 comments:

  1. sucks the Rogue Princess wasn't executed that well with the world building and some of the characters being kind of forgettable. Although a gender-swap retelling kind of sounds interesting to be honest.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I had high hopes, but unfortunately was a bit underwhelmed!

      Delete
  2. Rogue Princess sounds unique enough to intrigue me even though the world-building wasn't the best. It's the one I'd be most interested in reading out of all three.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Looks like no real strong ones here. Charlie Glass sounds really cute though, even if there is fat shaming.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, it was nice to pair all the books, but there wasn't a clear winner, unfortunately!

      Delete
  4. Bummer these were all meh reads for you! I have an aversion to retellings in general (unless they're Alice in Wonderland), because they never quite meet my expectations. The Lunar Chronicles is the only one I can think of on the top of my head that was just WOW.

    Lindsi @ Do You Dog-ear? 💬

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The Lunar Chronicles definitely set the bar high!

      Delete
  5. I love Cinderella retellinggs and Rogue Princess had caught my eye before, so I'm sorry to hear it didn't feel very new or fresh. Charlie Glass's slippers sounds cute though!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It was cute, though it kind of felt a bit dated!

      Delete
  6. Glad these were mostly good! I think it's cool how we're getting so many retellings of classic stories, with a sci- fi setting or whatever.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, it's always interesting to see a classic being updated!

      Delete
  7. Charlie Glass's Slippers sounds cute. That's too bad about Rogue Princess. It sounded really promising but I think the poor worldbuilding and not having a clear sense of who the characters were by the end would bother me too.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I know, and I had high hopes for it, too! I think fantasy books and I are just not getting along these days.

      Delete

I'm so glad you stopped by, and I would love to hear your thoughts! Comments are always greatly appreciated!