The Silent Companions by Laura Purcell (2017)
After her husband's death, Elsie is sent to his family's country estate to await the birth of her child. The sojourn, however, is anything but calming as strange things start happening around the house, including the appearance of several life-like wooden figures.
If you're looking for a spooky read without too much gore, this is the book for you. An estate that everyone in the local village stays away from, possessed portraits - this story had such a strong eerie, gothic feel to it without being cheesy. The book is told through three storylines: Elsie's time at The Bridge, the estate, in 1865; Elsie's time at an insane asylum (and because she's being accused of murder, you know something went down at The Bridge); and through the diary of an ancestor, which shed some light on the house's current creepy issues.
I loved Elsie; she's very strong and pragmatic, definitely ahead of her time. She doesn't want to believe something weird is going on at The Bridge, that there must be some explanation. If it were me, and sinister wooden paintings were appearing and moving around my house, I'd be out of there in a second. I though the origin portion of the story was interesting, but it was also a little outlandish and didn't necessarily fit with the feel of the rest of the book. 4 stars
The Widow's House by Carol Goodman (2017)
Jess and Clare move to a small town in the Hudson Valley to work on their marriage and their writing, but the house at which they become caretakers has a dark past, and it may be coming to get them.
Unfortunately, this book was a huge disappointment for me. It wasn't scary, spooky, or eerie at all. It felt cheesy, and the author's attempts to create tension all fell flat. It seemed like she took every cliché and threw it all into one book. Haunted house? Check. Mental asylum? Check. Weird puppets? Check. Potential psychic abilities? Check. Family secrets? Check.
The whole backstory to the house's past seemed simple (a woman and her newborn freeze to death one night), but the author made it so convoluted and repetitive. Poor Clare was just a mess - she had a crappy childhood; she ended up in an institution for a little while; her husband was one of the most selfish and manipulative characters I've come across. It seemed like everything bad that could happen to her, did. There was a big twist in this book that actually could have been really cool, but like everything else, it was so overdone and over-the-top that I couldn't help but roll my eyes. 2 stars
I want to read The Silent Companions so badly. It sounds like something I would really enjoy. I'm pretty much already sold on it. lol
ReplyDeleteHaha, I think you would enjoy it!
DeleteI've read The Widow's House and I'm pretty sure I liked it more than you did. Ha! I also own The Silent Companions and have heard good things. Definitely the time of year for these types of books. :-)
ReplyDeleteHaha, glad you enjoyed it! I would definitely recommend The Silent Companions, especially for this time of year!
DeleteThe Silent Companions sounds amazing! I don't enjoy books with lots of gore, so it is right up my alley. I'm sorry that The Widow's House wasn't what you had hoped for. The concept seems intriguing, though.
ReplyDeleteI'm with you, I'm not great with gore, so this was just right for me!
DeleteOhhh! The Silent Companions sound creepy! Also, is this the same Carol Goodman who wrote Blythewood--the witchy-YA series?
ReplyDeleteI just looked it up and yes, it's the same author! I haven't read anything else by her, though.
DeleteI love spooky books! I haven’t read either of these, but I really like the cover and title of The Silent Companions.
ReplyDeleteAj @ Read All The Things!
Yes, it was the cover that initially drew me to the book! Matches the story perfectly!
DeleteI loved The Silent Companions! I totally agree--I would've left right away haha, I'm not going to deal with spooky things in my house if I can help it. Bummer that The Widow House didn't work out! It does get annoying when authors just throw in all of the cliches and seem to think that makes it good. I read The Lake of Dead Languages by Carol Goodman and (I think?) I enjoyed it, so I'd been curious about some of her other work. Great reviews!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Jordan! Right, way too many cliches, just pick a couple and do them well!
DeleteThe Silent Companions sounds like a good choice for me. I don't mind spooky but gore is definitely not my thing. That's a shame about The Widow's House. The premise sounds good, but the whole overdone, over-the-top style would be a turnoff for me as well.
ReplyDeleteYeah, I really enjoyed The Silent Companions - great atmospheric read!
DeleteAw that's a shame about The Widow's House...
ReplyDeleteYeah, it was a bummer, I was really looking forward to it!
Delete